Email Print Comments 6Share retweet 16 Associated Press
ALLISON, Iowa -- An Iowa man charged with killing a nationally known high school football coach could have carefully planned the shooting and still been insane, his defense attorneys maintained Wednesday, while prosecutors told jurors that argument didn't make sense.
Attorneys presented their closing arguments to jurors Wednesday morning in the first-degree murder trial of Mark Becker, 24, who is accused of fatally shooting Aplington-Parkersburg coach Ed Thomas on June 24, 2009.
“
This entire case is about Mark Becker's state of mind. And whenever you look and examine Mark Becker's state of mind, you have to look at what he did, not just what some experts say about it.
”
-- Scott Brown,
Assistant Iowa Attorney General
Becker has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. The 12-person jury began deliberating the case early Wednesday afternoon.
Becker gunned down Thomas, 58, in the school's makeshift weight room in front of students, shooting him at least six times before walking away.
Becker told police that Thomas was Satan and that the coach had been tormenting him.
The shooting was especially shocking to Parkersburg residents because Thomas was known both for producing winning teams and for leading the community.
Though the defense doesn't dispute that Becker shot Thomas, and prosecutors agree that Becker suffers from paranoid schizophrenia, the question is Becker's mental status on the morning he shot Thomas.
To prove Becker is insane, the defense had to show he didn't understand the nature and quality of his acts and he wasn't able to distinguish right from wrong.
During closing arguments, assistant Iowa Attorney General Scott Brown focused on Becker's actions the morning of June 24. Becker was arrested after the shooting as he drove up to his house.
Defense attorneys referred back to mental health experts, who said [Mark] Becker could have rationally planned the shooting despite his irrational belief that Thomas was trying to control his mind with telepathic messages.
"This entire case is about Mark Becker's state of mind," Brown told the jury. "And whenever you look and examine Mark Becker's state of mind, you have to look at what he did, not just what some experts say about it."
Defense attorneys referred back to mental health experts, who said Becker could have rationally planned the shooting despite his irrational belief that Thomas was trying to control his mind with telepathic messages.
One defense expert, Cleveland psychiatrist Phillip Resnick, had introduced the jury to the concept of "rationality within irrationality." He testified that Becker could have taken rational steps -- such as loading a .22-caliber pistol and taking practice shots -- while still being insane at the time of the shooting.
Public defender Susan Flander said psychiatrists who testified for the prosecution ignored that concept, bringing their opinions into question.
"[The concept] is undisputed," Flander said. "They just ignored it, and because they ignored it, it just doesn't exist. There is no inconsistency between careful planning and insanity."
Brown dismissed Resnick's theory.
"This is something of Dr. Resnick's own making," Brown said. "It really kind of makes no sense. If you have sufficient mental capacity, it sort of doesn't go together that you were irrational. ... His phrasing is simply not part of Iowa law."
Flander, as she had done during the trial, included evidence of previous delusional episodes in which Thomas smashed bathroom walls in his parents' house and other episodes in which he had to be detained by police and committed to a psychiatric ward.
Copyright 2010 by The Associated Press
Post Archive
-
▼
2010
(954)
-
▼
February
(307)
- Man arrested in teen's disappearance
- Attackers Kill 11 in Philippines
- No more Kennedys? Family mulls a political comeback
- Netherlands gay protest over Catholic communion snub
- Iraqi PM accused of handing out guns in bid to buy...
- Further arrests over Huddersfield shopkeeper killing
- Sheriff says crime scene beyond 'heinous'
- Reports: Khabibulin faces new charge
- Reports: Jefferson charged with DWI
- Shaq to have thumb examined Sunday
- Chile Toll at 700; 2 Million Are Displaced
- Storms Kill at Least 15 in France
- Venus Williams wins the Mexican Open final
- Woman killed as downpours and floods hit UK
- Marie Osmond's teenage son dies
- Sources: Jones to become free agent
- Hawaii Exhales as Tsunami Warning Is Canceled
- Third suspect arrested in Juarez party killings
- Bears claim share of first conference title since ...
- Tsunami waves from Chilean quake arrive in Japan
- Rain triggers deadly floods in Haiti
- Airplanes and alligators mix at remote Everglades ...
- Nets top Celtics for sixth win of season, third on...
- How U.S. Olympians pay the rent
- Harvick pulls out victory at Vegas
- Canada curlers clinch 13th gold medal
- Chile quake 'affects two million'
- Page's key 3-pointers help Cowboys hand Jayhawks f...
- NFL could change overtime format for playoffs
- U.S. and Canada in Fight for Olympic Hockey Gold
- Rams keeping open mind about draft's top pick
- Bills decline to offer Owens contract
- Unlikely Activist Who Got to the Tea Party Early
- U.S. wins first four-man gold since 1948
- Heat's Wade out again with calf injury
- 2 US Airways planes clip wings at National airport
- 'Miracle' diet pill maker gets 20 years in prison
- Fighting Irish keep chugging without Harangody
- No. 17 Tennessee ends 8-game streak of No. 2 Kentucky
- Device fired at police station in Northern Ireland
- Keselowski wins pole in Vegas
- Stern expects approval in March
- Nexus One coming to Verizon March 23rd?
- Marshall IDs suspect in murder trial
- 19 killed in firecracker explosion in China
- California Campus Sees Uneasy Race Relations
- MJ to buy controlling stake in Bobcats
- Calipari focused on seeding, not SEC
- 26 dead in Timbuktu mosque stampede
- Biden scheduled to visit Florida next week
- Gatorade Drops Tiger Woods
- How To Braid Puff Pastry
- Bynum fined for criticizing refs
- Tsunami alert as a quake strikes off Japan
- Source: Chargers do not tender Sproles
- White House Social Secretary Desiree Rogers Steps ...
- The Online Dating Recession
- Charges contained in arrest warrant
- Shanahan: Redskins to tender Campbell
- US killer whale show to resume after trainer is ki...
- Police investigating claim 13-year-old raped at Do...
- Moore helps Huskies get 18th straight win vs. Orange
- Two Men Face New Charges in Terror Plot
- Calif. Deputy Dead, Officer Critical After Shooting
- ‘American Idol’: Who Will Be the First to Say Good...
- Police Say Actor Andrew Koenig Found Dead
- Canada outclass US to take gold in ice hockey
- At Closing Plant, Ordeal Included Heart Attacks
- Hummel hurts knee but Grant thwarts Gophers' upset...
- Brazil's Lula says Fidel Castro is 'exceptionally ...
- Coke in Talks to Buy U.S. Unit of Its Biggest Bottler
- Fla. woman sues 50 Cent over release of sex tape
- Is Sex Addiction an Excuse?
- No criminal charges for Irvin
- Hooded gunmen kill 13 in southern Mexico
- Three NYPD Officers Acquitted in Police Brutality ...
- State officials: More than 1,000 gangs in Florida
- Tomlinson: No reason given for release
- Ex-cop pleads guilty in Katrina bridge shooting
- Cliff Lee feels good after session
- Math teacher called `hero' for tackling gunman in ...
- Dubai Names 15 More Suspects in Hamas Leader's Death
- Drone pilots have a front-row seat on war, from ha...
- ‘Evita’ Revival Planned for Broadway
- Charlie Sheen Enters Rehabilitation Center
- Guns Now Legal In National Parks
- Two men die in Glencoe avalanche
- Belfast pair given life for the murder of Thomas D...
- Hundreds remain ill on cruise ship, company says
- ‘Millennials’ More Pro-Government Than Older Ameri...
- How To Make Meatballs
- Jury deliberating Becker's case
- SeaWorld trainer killed by killer whale
- IRS worker's widow sues Texas suicide pilot's wife
- Americans Flatt, Nagasu sit 5th, 6th
- Kobe nets 32, including game-winning 3, in return ...
- Nigerian President Umaru Yar'Adua 'returns home'
- 10-K Watch: New York Times, By the—Reduced—Numbers
- Toyota dealers rally in defense of brand
- Paul Pierce out with bad thumb, flu
-
▼
February
(307)
No comments:
Post a Comment